Logic and Debate

I. Collected topics

Ngag-wang-tra-shiā€™s The Collected Topics of Epistemology:

Chapters 1-12: Topography of the Tibetan Intellectual World, and How to Debate It ā†—

Steven Weinberger

Chapter 21: Presentation of Negatives and Positives ā†—

Jeffrey Hopkins

Presentation of Specifically and Generally Characterized Phenomena by Den-dar-hla-ram-ba ā†—

Anne C. Klein

Includes oral commentary from Denma Locho Rinbochay and Kensur Losang Wangdu

Oral Debate ā†—

Lati Rinbochay, Jeffrey Hopkins

Debates on colors, established bases, reverses, opposites

Dharmakīrti

II. Pramāį¹‡avārttika

Why Did DharmakÄ«rti Write The Commentary? Jam-yang-zhay-paā€™s Decisive Analysis of DharmakÄ«rtiā€™s ā€œCommentary on Valid Cognitionā€ Introduction 1 ā†—

Hiroshi Nemoto

In collaboration with Lo-sang-gyal-tshan

III. Signs and reasonings

Jam-yang-zhay-paā€™s Illuminating a Little the Presentation of Signs and Reasonings: Beautiful Golden Garland of Eloquence

Part 1: How Can a Conclusion Be Drawn From a Sign? ā†—

Katherine Rogers

Part 2: What Constitutes a Correct Reason? ā†—

Katherine Rogers

Part 3: Reasoning From Effects ā†—

Katherine Rogers

Scroll to Top